Jim Hartman’s post-election autopsy, published in the Nevada Appeal’s weekend edition, is at least partly right. Nevada Republicans suffered a brutal defeat, and Donald Trump’s unpopularity was undoubtedly a major reason. But it seems to me that Hartman’s explanation lets Nevada Republicans off too easily.

He portrays Trump almost as a natural disaster that descended upon otherwise sensible Republican candidates. Gov. Joe Lombardo had a respectable record. Controller Andy Matthews was competent. Republicans had money and experienced campaign organizations. Then along came the anti-Trump tsunami and swept them away.

There’s a problem with that explanation: Republicans chose Trump. He wasn’t imposed on the Republican Party by Democrats, the news media or some outside force. Republican voters chose him. Republican politicians embraced him. Republican organizations accommodated him. And candidates seeking Republican nominations learned that loyalty to Trump was more important than appealing to the broader electorate they would eventually have to face.

Hartman himself provides two excellent Nevada examples. He describes Republican 2nd Congressional District nominee David Flippo as a scandal-plagued “carpetbagger” and Trump acolyte who became an embarrassment to the party. He describes Republican secretary of state candidate Jim Marchant as a “kook” who promoted outlandish election conspiracy theories.

Democrats didn’t nominate Flippo and Marchant. Republicans did.

Hartman gives considerable credit to Lombardo while giving remarkably little to the Democrats who defeated Republicans. For example, Controller Andy Matthews is described as a “rising conservative star” who did a highly credible job, while his Democratic opponent, Michael MacDougall, is dismissed as having “no apparent qualifications.”

MacDougall did lack the incumbent’s government experience and had no professional background in accounting or auditing. But the 32-year-old does hold a bachelor’s degree and two graduate degrees, has worked as an educator, and has articulated specific policy positions on financial reporting, debt collection, and fiscal transparency. He’s a high achiever who is clearly up to the challenge. Describing his résumé as nonexistent is political rhetoric, not a fair assessment.

Considering that Democrats won the governorship, swept the statewide constitutional offices, captured every congressional district and expanded their legislative majorities, Republicans should consider the possibility that Nevadans weren’t merely voting against Trump or Republicans generally. They may also have been voting for Democrats.

That doesn’t mean Nevada has suddenly become a deeply progressive state. It hasn’t. Nevada voters remain independent-minded and perfectly capable of voting differently from one race or issue to another. Nor does it mean Democrats should interpret one spectacular election as a permanent mandate. Political fortunes can change remarkably quickly.

But neither should Republicans, for their part, dismiss this election as something that simply happened to them because Donald Trump was unpopular.

Hartman concludes that the Nevada Republican Party needs new leadership. He may well be right. But replacing Michael McDonald won’t solve the deeper problem if Republican primary voters continue nominating candidates whom even a thoughtful conservative like Jim Hartman considers unfit for office.

The Republican Party faces a fundamental choice. Is Trumpism an unfortunate burden that somehow attached itself to an otherwise healthy Republican Party? Or is Trumpism the political identity Republicans have repeatedly chosen?

Hartman deserves credit for honestly acknowledging the magnitude of the Republican defeat and some of his party’s self-inflicted wounds. But Republicans can’t reform their party until they acknowledge who inflicted those wounds. Donald Trump didn’t hijack the Republican Party. Republicans gave him the keys.

Rich Dunn can be reached at richdunn@aol.com.


Interested in having your voice heard? We want to hear from you. 

Learn how to submit an Opinion Piece or a Letter to the Editors.