It was anticipated that items relating to the ongoing City Hall / downtown development projects would be the hot topic of the night at Wednesday’s meeting of the Carson City Planning Commission.
However, before those items could even begin, sparks flew after a Planning Commissioner said she received communication from the Carson City District Attorney’s office only hours before the meeting stating she should recuse herself from discussions and voting or she could open herself up to be sued — and have to defend herself personally.
‘A perceived conflict of interest’
At the beginning of an item discussing the abandonment of streets to the Hop and Mae Adams Foundation for a proposed parking garage and/or “future development,” Carson City Planning Commissioner Teri Preston read — or refused to read — a disclosure regarding a “perceived conflict of interest.”
Preston said she had been advised only hours before that she should not participate in the two items, and that if she did not, she could face a potential lawsuit and/or an ethics violation.
Preston said this is due to comments she’d made during previous Board of Supervisor’s meetings in which she, acting in her private capacity as a commercial real estate agent, questioned why a property she represented had not been considered as an alternative in a search for a new City Hall.
She said the DA’s office informed her that, because of these comments, she could be seen as having a “perceived conflict.” And, if she did vote on the item, and an ethics complaint or any other lawsuit were filed against her as a result of her voting, the city would not defend her, as they had advised her against it prior to the item being heard.
However, Preston said if she had a conflict of interest, she would have disclosed it herself. Specifically, she said that the property being referenced as disqualifying her from participation is currently under contract with a separate entity — meaning it could not be chosen as an alternative City Hall at this point even if the city wanted it.
“The property is currently under contract, which will be coming before this body next month — which I will recuse myself from, because I would actually benefit from it.”
Preston also said in her statement that she had been requested in her private capacity to bring forward the property for consideration as an alternative by city officials.
It should be noted that city staff have stated multiple times both during public meetings as well as in response to Carson Now’s questions that the property, along with a handful of others, was evaluated and determined not to be a good fit for a City Hall.
“The City Hall is not on this agenda tonight — what is on this agenda is the abandonment of streets, and a parking lot,” Preston said. “But unfortunately, as it stands, I risk my personal — I could be sued individually because of the perception.”
Preston became visibly upset during her comment, stating that in her nine years serving on the commission, she has acted fairly, and has always been very clear when she is speaking in her different capacities.
“I have never felt so forced to read this statement,” she said before turning to a printed paper.
However, Preston did not read the disclosure statement verbatim, as she apparently disagreed with a number of the statements included. Instead, she edited it verbally — “I’m not going to say a ‘conflict’ I’m going to say a ‘perceived conflict’” — or refused to read portions of it altogether.
The statement had been made by the DA’s office, Preston said, and provided to her to read.
At the end of her statement, Preston read, in part, from an additional document provided to her by the DA’s office informing her that if she abstained she could still discuss the item, but that “I’ve gotta kinda mind my P’s and Q’s” because it could be perceived as advocating for or against the project, which she was told she could not do, or risk liability.
“I’m being put in a position where I cannot speak as an individual, and I cannot speak [as a commissioner], and I think this is very unfortunate,” Preston said. “Because I think I have more knowledge about this property than anyone in this room.”
Preston explained she helped to sell the very piece of land the parking garage is proposed to be placed on back in the 1980s, and that she is “very familiar” with the properties and the various proposals to develop it over the years.
Preston then left the meeting.
Senior Deputy District Attorney Mihaela Neagos addressed Preston’s comments, stating that it’s her duty as the commission’s counsel to inform members if the DA’s office believes a conflict to exist which commissioners should disclose. She said they write those disclosures for commissioners “as a courtesy.”
Neagos ended by stating that it’s every commission member’s duty to reach out to the DA’s office to discuss potential conflicts of interest.
However, according to Preston’s prior comments, it was the DA’s office who reached out to Preston about what they saw as her perceived conflict, not Preston reaching out for advice.
We’ve reached out to the city and to Preston for comments.
Up next: meeting coverage.
